AbracadabraNYC Review (2026): Halloween Costumes, Makeup & Coupon Code
AbracadabraNYC is a New York City specialty shop for Halloween costumes, theatrical makeup, wigs, and special effects supplies. Prices range from $1.00 to $14.95. Verified 10% off coupon available.
AbracadabraNYC is a New York City specialty retailer selling Halloween costumes, theatrical makeup, wigs, props, and collectibles. Based on the store's product pages reviewed in September 2026, prices on the best-selling list range from $1.00 for a branded tote bag to $14.95 for a special effects adhesive kit. The Abracadabra NYC Reusable Shopping Bag is the store's #1 best seller. A verified 10% off coupon code is available — see the coupon section below.
What is AbracadabraNYC?
AbracadabraNYC is a costume, cosplay, and theatrical supply retailer based in New York City. According to the store's description, AbracadabraNYC carries magic, costumes, makeup, rentals, props, wigs, and more, and operates physical store locations in NYC where customers can walk in or use in-store pickup.
The product lineup includes theatrical-grade face and body paints, grease paints, stage blood, special effects adhesives, wig caps, and branded merchandise. AbracadabraNYC stocks products from brands including Mehron and Ben Nye, which the product descriptions note are used in theater and film makeup contexts. Online orders are supported by multiple shipping options including same-day delivery within approximately 20 miles of the store.
AbracadabraNYC Best Sellers
Abracadabra NYC Reusable Shopping Bag
According to the product page, this tote bag features the store's iconic gargoyle graphic and store information. The bag measures approximately 18" x 12" x 7" when fully opened, with textured handles for grip. It is #1 on the store's best-seller list, with 1 variant listed. The store's product page displays a rating of 4.87 out of 5 from 15 reviews.
Mehron Paradise AQ Face & Body Paint
According to the product page, Mehron describes this body paint as a buttery-smooth formula producing opaque color available in matte and metallic hues, suitable for all skin types. The product page states it is vegan, cruelty-free, gluten-free, and paraben-free. It is #2 on the store's best-seller list. The product page lists 48 variants by color.
Mehron Color Cups Grease Paint
According to the product page, this grease paint has a thick, creamy consistency suited for Halloween makeup. The product description notes it can be applied with fingertips, sponge, or brush, and that shades can be mixed using a spatula. It is #3 on the store's best-seller list. The product page lists 11 variants by color. The store's product page displays a rating of 5.0 out of 5 from 2 reviews.
Mehron Fantasy FX Theatrical Cream Makeup
According to the product page, Mehron describes this water-based cream makeup as highly pigmented and suitable for both kids and adults for Halloween and costume applications. The product page notes it removes easily with soap and water. It is #4 on the store's best-seller list. The product page lists 12 variants by color.
AbracadabraNYC Prices at a Glance
| Product | Price | Was | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reusable Shopping Bag | $1.00 | — | 1 variant listed; #1 best seller |
| Mehron Paradise AQ Body Paint | $13.95 | — | 48 variants listed |
| Mehron Color Cups Grease Paint | $7.95 | — | 11 variants listed |
| Mehron Fantasy FX Cream Makeup | $6.95 | — | 12 variants listed |
| Wig Cap | $4.95 | — | 2 variants listed |
| Mehron Spirit Gum Adhesive w/ Remover | $14.95 | — | 1 variant listed |
| Ben Nye Stage Blood | $6.95 | — | 4 variants listed |
| Mehron Stage Blood | $7.95 | — | 8 variants listed |
Pros and Cons
Pros
- A verified 10% off coupon code is available — see the coupon section below
- In-store pickup available at 2 NYC locations, per the shipping policy
- Same-day delivery offered for addresses within approximately 20 miles of the store, per the shipping policy
- International shipping available for most products, per the shipping policy
- Entry pricing starts at $1.00, with most theatrical makeup items under $15
Cons
- All sales are final — the refund policy states no refunds, returns, or exchanges for sanitary reasons
- Damaged or missing items must be reported within 1–2 days of package arrival
- Free shipping is available once a spending threshold is met, but the policy reviewed does not state the specific dollar amount
- No customer ratings are displayed on most product pages reviewed
AbracadabraNYC suits shoppers looking for theatrical Halloween makeup, wigs, special effects supplies, and costumes from a New York City specialty retailer. The main trade-off is the all-sales-final return policy, which means buyers should be confident in their selections before ordering. A verified 10% off coupon is available and applies to the order total, which helps offset costs on larger purchases.
Shipping and Returns
According to AbracadabraNYC's shipping policy, domestic orders can be shipped via Ground, Expedited 2nd Day, or Next Day options (excluding weekends and holidays). Same-day delivery is available for addresses within approximately 20 miles of the store or warehouse. In-store pickup is available at 2 locations. All orders are dispatched by 2pm ET; orders placed after that cutoff may require local pickup or next-business-day processing. International shipping is available for most products; customs and import duties are not included and are the buyer's responsibility. Free shipping is available once a certain order threshold is met — the policy reviewed does not state the specific dollar amount.
According to AbracadabraNYC's refund policy, all transactions are final due to the sanitary nature of the products. No refunds, returns, or exchanges are accepted. In the event that an item arrives damaged or with missing parts, the store asks that you leave the product untouched and contact them within 1–2 days of the package arriving at (212) 627-5197 or [email protected]. Partial refunds may be granted at management's discretion in such cases.
Is There an AbracadabraNYC Coupon Code?
This code was verified by applying it in an anonymous cart on September 30, 2026. Discount terms and availability may change — check the Koupora page for AbracadabraNYC for the most current offers.
Who Should Buy from AbracadabraNYC (and Who Should Skip It)?
Good fit
- Shoppers looking for Halloween costumes, cosplay supplies, and theatrical makeup in one place
- Buyers who want access to professional makeup brands such as Mehron and Ben Nye, which the product descriptions note are used in professional settings
- Customers near New York City who can take advantage of in-store pickup, same-day delivery, or walk-in at 2 locations
- Anyone who can use the verified 10% off coupon to save on a larger order
Might skip
- Shoppers who may need to return items — the all-sales-final policy means no refunds, returns, or exchanges
- Buyers purchasing items where fit or sizing verification is important, since returns are not accepted
- Anyone who needs a clearly stated free shipping threshold before ordering
How We Researched This Review
This review was prepared by Koupora's editorial team by reviewing AbracadabraNYC's product pages, pricing, and policies as they appeared in September 2026. We did not personally test or purchase any of the products. Prices, availability, and policies can change at any time — always verify on the store's website before ordering. Koupora may earn a commission on purchases made through links on this page.
AbracadabraNYC FAQ
Is AbracadabraNYC legit?
Based on product pages and policies reviewed in September 2026, AbracadabraNYC is a specialty costume and theatrical makeup retailer with physical store locations in New York City. The store offers in-store pickup at 2 NYC locations, ships via tracked carriers, and carries theatrical makeup brands including Mehron and Ben Nye, according to the product pages reviewed.
Does AbracadabraNYC ship to the US?
Yes. According to the shipping policy, US orders can be shipped via Ground, Expedited 2nd Day, or Next Day options. Same-day delivery is also available for addresses within approximately 20 miles of the store. All orders ship by 2pm ET on business days. Free shipping applies once a certain order threshold is met; the specific dollar amount is not stated in the policy reviewed.
Does AbracadabraNYC have a coupon code?
Yes. The code CARROLLTIMEOUTPS gives 10% off and was verified by applying it in an anonymous cart on September 30, 2026. Visit the Koupora page for AbracadabraNYC to check for any updated offers.
What is AbracadabraNYC's return policy?
According to the refund policy, all sales are final. No refunds, returns, or exchanges are accepted due to the sanitary nature of the products. If an item arrives damaged or with missing parts, contact the store within 1–2 days of delivery at (212) 627-5197 or [email protected]. Partial refunds may be considered at management's discretion.
Does AbracadabraNYC ship internationally?
According to the shipping policy, most products can be shipped internationally. Customs and import duties are not included and are the buyer's responsibility, as the store has no control over those charges.
